Why Should Reading Be a Contest?

I recently saw a blog urging writers to plow through 100 books a year to make themselves better writers. 100 seems to be some kind of current yardstick, though I don’t know why.

I think that’s another sad example of how numbers-crazy we’ve become as writers. Reading widely is good advice for writers of all kinds.  But why should the amount of books you read in a year actually matter as opposed to what you read and what you learn from those books. Isn’t how they they inspire you what really counts?

Take a unique book like Rebecca West’s astonishing Black Lamb and Grey Falcon. It’s a record of the author’s travels through the Balkans before World War II. The book is part travelogue, part history, part cultural portrait, and reads throughout with the color and drama of a novel. It’s 1200 pages long and might take you weeks or more to read, but you can learn a lot from every aspect of it, including West’s gorgeous prose style.


I read it one summer while touring Italy and France and felt as if I I’d died and gone to literary heaven. I didn’t finish it on my month-long trip because I was also enjoying sightseeing (big surprise!) and because the book was so luscious it was like a ballotin of Neuhaus chocolates. Something to be savored, not devoured. I read many passages more than once, sometimes read them aloud just to enjoy their sound in the Tuscan or Parisian air. That summer, I read almost nothing else.

What if you wanted to spend a whole year just reading and re-reading all of F. Scott Fitzgerald’s books so as to immerse yourself in his style and vision? What would be wrong with that? Wouldn’t you learn an enormous amount as a writer?  Maybe more than if you just randomly picked 100 books?  I wager the blog author might call you lazy, though, because she recommends a blitzkrieg. Seriously. Reading as battle, bombing, conquest, and devastation. What kind of attitude is that?

Everything’s become a frantic contest now, which makes us all potential losers. A writing career is hard enough as it it, and we’re already under assault by the word count fanatics–as I recently blogged at The Huffington Post.

When does it stop?  When the hell does it stop?

 Raphael is the author of Assault With a Deadly Lie, a novel of suspense about stalking, gun violence, and militarized police–along 24 other books in many genres which you can find at Amazon.

2 thoughts on “Why Should Reading Be a Contest?”

  1. Many years ago I had a roommate who was a voracious reader. When I asked him to read me a passage from one of the books he was enjoying at the time, I was shocked by his response. He read the passage out loud as quickly as he could in a complete monotone. There was absolutely no appreciation for meter, flow, or the music of language. It was like watching a 15-year-old boy boast about how quickly he had reached orgasm with no idea that, as the old Cunard Line motto told us, “Getting there is half the fun.”

    One reason I have resisted the fetish for measuring how many hits I’m getting on each post as a measure of success is that it’s a completely ridiculous statistic. The number of hits gives no indication of the impact of one’s writing on the reader or his level of enjoyment.

    • What a great story! And your point on “hits” is well-taken. There’s no way of knowing how what one writes affects people–sometimes it moves them to reflection. That doesn’t show up anywhere we can see. But it’s important. Same with reviews on Amazon or elsewhere…..


Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.